What you need:
- a landing page with a lead magnet
- a software that records heat maps and sessions (you can sign up for a free trial just for this exercise)
- 1-3 hours of your time.
What you don’t need:
- to have posted on StumbleUpon before
- to interact with others on StumbleUpon
- to have a following.
What you get:
- lots of traffic and new subscribers from StumbleUpon
- a landing page that is better optimized for conversions and more subscribers (in the long run)
- How StumbleUpon works (and why should you care)
- Optimize your page for StumbleUpon users in advance
- Create a StumbleUpon account (free)
- Prepare to record heatmaps and sessions (free)
- Submit your page to StumbleUpon
- How long will StumbleUpon keep showing your page to its users?
- Analyse user behavior and improve the page
This is a rather lengthy read. Grap this post as PDF to read later.
Have you heard stories of people just “dumping” a link on StumbleUpon and getting tons of traffic?
I didn’t believe them either.
Till that one day when I heard about it one time too often and decided to finally try it out.
So, on a yet another Tuesday when I was about to call it a day, I submitted a link to my website checklist to my newly created StumbleUpon account, closed the lid of my laptop and went to bed.
6 hours later, I woke up to 200+ views on a page that would usually get 10 views a day max.
I open my stats and discovered that all those views came from StumbleUpon.
Long story short, I was able to keep the momentum for 3 weeks that brought me 5K views and 80+ subscribers.
In this article, I’ll share with you the 5 steps you can follow to replicate this.
But before we start, we need to look into one more thing: StumbleUpon users – your target audience in this case, and how they view content.
How StumbleUpon works (and why you should care)
StumbleUpon is a bookmarklet site. Meaning you won’t see any personal thoughts or messages shared together with the submitted articles. People are just publically bookmarking the articles they liked, and that’s the end of it.
The pages you’ll see there were once submitted by someone who:
- either literally stumbled over an online article they liked and decided to submit (aka “stumble”) it
- or, like you and I, wanted to promote their own blog and “stumbled” the article totally on purpose.
The users of StumbleUpon can then discover those submitted articles by … in a rather unusual way:
Every time they click a big red “Stumble” button, they get to see a more or less random article based on the interests they specified in their profile and:
- whether the article was newly submitted
- or whether a lot of people still keep “liking” this article.
If you think “What’s the fun in looking at random articles?”, it’s probably the thrill and anticipation of the Unknown.
“Uuu, I wonder what article I get to see next time!”
And as you’ll also stumble upon great content that got thousands of likes, it’s a fun activity if you have some free time.
But you and I don’t have free time, so let’s move on.
What it means for your efforts to get traffic and subscribers
- As most of the people don’t actively choose to look at it, they have zero motivation to stay on your page. Meaning your headline and the opening paragraphs are crucial for convincing the StumbleUpon user to give your content a chance.
- For StumbleUpon to keep showing your page to its users (and for you to keep the traffic to it), the StumbleUpon users need to keep “liking” it.
So your key to success is to have a page where it’s clear from the first sentence that it’s ultra-helpful unique content. If your page is meh or just “good”, this isn’t going to work.
A side note: Regardless of StumbleUpon, if you want your content or lead magnet to get you leads, there is no way around it: It has to be exceptional.
But ok, let’s say your lead magnets blows the socks off your website visitors.
Here’s what you need to do next.
How to use StumbleUpon to get traffic and new subscribers
Step #1: Optimize your page for StumbleUpon users in advance.
Because of this whole “I didn’t ask for this article” situation, your visitors will be even less motivated to look at your content as usual. That’s why every word and image count.
Look at your page and:
- Make sure your headline communicates the benefit of reading your article clearly. Don’t be clever. Be clear.
- Tell people what to expect from your page right away and get to the point early on the page (consider cutting the storytelling).
- Provide a clear, compelling and visually prominent call to action as early as the benefit of your lead magnet becomes obvious.
- Make your page scannable and easy to process by sticking to the formatting best practices.
Do your best but don’t agonize over it. You’ll have a chance to improve things after you submit your page to StumbleUpon and see your visitors interact with the page.
Step #2: Create a StumbleUpon account (free)
If you don’t have a StumbleUpon account yet (I didn’t have one) sign up.
You don’t have to interact with anyone or post anything, or have any followers. It could be your first share on StumbleUpon ever (as it was in my case).
Step #3: Prepare to record heatmaps and sessions
This is the key to your long-term success: You need to see how your users interact with the page to be able to optimize it on the fly and to win more subscribers and likes.
Heatmaps will show you how far your visitors scroll and where they click.
Session recordings will show you a video of how a user interacted with the page in that particular session as if you were looking over their shoulder while they were browsing your website.
These tools are very easy to install. All you need to do is to copy-paste a piece of code they give you into your website’s header.
I used a free trial of HotJar, but you can take any other software that provides the same info (LuckyOrange, Crazy Egg, etc.)
See if you need to tell your software to start recording a heatmap for the page you are going to submit to StumbleUpon (it doesn’t always do it automatically).
For example, in HotJar you need to go to Heatmaps -> New Heatmap:
While you are at it (and while your trial is active), also create a heat map for other pages that get some traffic to optimize them (this has nothing to do with StumbleUpon, but why not kill a couple of birds with this one stone).
Step #4: Submit your page to StumbleUpon.
It’s show time. Let’s submit your page to StumbleUpon.
- Go to your profile and click “Add a Page”
- Paste your URL
- Select “Yes” to indicate it’s safe for work (Still not sure what it means, though. Probably that it’s for the people to view it at work. Which raises another question: How the hell does StumbleUpon knows people are at work?!)
- Specify one interest under which you’d like to submit this page. Start typing, and StumbleUpon will autosuggest stuff.
- Specify the tags.
Regarding the tags: Weird story. It’s unclear what’s the best way to do it.
While submitting your post, you can specify as many tags as you like, and call them whatever you like. But StumbleUpon neither autosuggests the tags nor displays them for the already submitted articles. Totally weird.
Here’s an “unofficial snapshot” of all the interests and popular tags as of March 2014 (I couldn’t find any fresh data, unfortunately).
After you submit your page, StumbleUpon will show it to roughly 50 users whose interests match the interest (and I’m assuming the tags) of the page you submitted.
Important: Make sure your page hasn’t been submitted to StumbleUpon before
To get the initial 50 views and a chance to build momentum it’s important that your page has been never submitted to StumbleUpon before under that particular URL.
To double-check, submit your page and immediately check the number of likes on it. If it’s larger than 1, it means someone has already “stumbled” it, and you are not going to get this initial boost of 50 views.
It’s fixable, though.
If your page has already been submitted to StumbleUpon:
- Duplicate the page under a different URL (for example, yourwebsite.com/my-page-2) but set it to “noindex” to tell Google not to index it (otherwise you’ll have a problem with duplicate content).
- Submit the page under the new URL.
For example, Yoast SEO plug-in under WordPress lets you do it in the post editor in the section where you specify the meta title and meta description for the post (under “Advanced” setting):
Depending on how many likes your page will get and from whom (users with big following vs users with small following), StumbleUpon will:
- stop showing your page after the initial 50 views because not enough people “liked” it
- or keep showing it while people are still “liking” it.
How long will StumbleUpon keep showing your page to its users?
While I was getting the traffic from StumbleUpon to my page, I was keeping an eye on the number of views from one side, and the number of likes it got on StumbleUpon.
I noticed that it was still getting 100+ visits a day while the likes-to-views ratio was around 10,5%. I stopped getting traffic from StumbleUpon when the likes-to-views ratio dropped to 10,1% (yes, I was literally measuring this a couple of times a day; and yes, I actually have a life).
So my initial assumption was that StumbleUpon displays an article while enough people are liking it.
To confirm this, I looked at 30 articles and noted down the number of likes and visits they had at 9am vs 9pm. If I saw a substantial increase in the number of visits at 9pm, it meant that StumbleUpon is still displaying the article to a lot of users.
I was hoping to see a correlation between the links-to-visits ratio and whether an article was still getting traffic from StumbleUpon.
Unfortunately, StumbleUpon makes it impossible to gather enough data, as it insists on displaying random stuff and I don’t have a whole week to do this.
Among the 30 articles, I got only 3 articles with a likes-to-views ratio over 10%. 2 out of 3 of them weren’t being displayed anymore.
But fun fact: StumbleUpon stopped showing the viewers all of the articles with the likes-to-views ratio below 10% (27 out of 30).
What does it mean for you?
It does look like that the articles that not many people like stop getting traffic, we just don’t know the exact number.
So it’s important that your article gets an initial boost of likes and keeps a high likes-to-views ratio.
I was lucky enough for it to happen by itself but if I did it again I would team up with a couple of friends and ask them to “like” it.
Is it 100% fair game?
Hm, I would say it’s a gray-ish area. But it’s also unfair that luck has a say in whether your great content gets the exposure it deserves (maybe all those stumblers who would have loved your article went to bed when you submitted it and didn’t get a chance to “like” it). So it’s just a small compensation for your bad luck 🙂
Step #5. Analyse how the users interact with the page to improve it and keep the momentum
It’s important that you keep a close look on things in the first couple of hours.
Check your heatmap and session recordings.
How far do the users scroll? Where do they click? Are all images displayed correctly?
If you see users leaving the page too soon or not clicking on your call-to-action buttons, think about what could be the case and update the page.
Make sure to delete the existing heatmap after you update the page and create a new heatmap, as the design of your page has changed and you won’t be able to see the correct data if you keep using the old heatmap.
Watching your users interact with the page will also help you discover broken links and problems with your page on different devices and browsers.
For example, I discovered that one of my call-to-action links was broken (#facepalm) and that one image wasn’t properly rendering for iPhones.
Optimizing your page based on user interactions: Example
When I initially submitted my page to StumbleUpon, it looked like this:
Do you see a problem?
Well, I didn’t see the problem at that time, but I noticed that initially, I was getting hundreds of views but only a few subscribers.
I looked at my heatmap and session recordings and saw that a lot of people won’t scrolling far enough to see the infographic.
“OMG, where are you going?! You’ve missed the main thing!”
So I quickly did this:
- I cut out the long story in the beginning and told people what to expect from the page with as few words as possible.
- I placed the infographic higher on the page making part of it visible above the fold.
- I removed the “add this image to your website” code snippet I had after the infographic and left only one call to action: The “Download” button.
- I added a line that explained why the PDF you could download is better than the infographic.
- I added a gray background to make call to action visually prominent.
Here’s how my optimized page looked like:
I started getting more subscribers and was able to keep the momentum for 3 weeks.
But most importantly, I now get more subscribers organically, because this page ranks in search (which has nothing to do with StumbleUpon) and is now better optimized for conversions (as the result of this StumbleUpon exercise).
Not bad for a couple of hours of effort, I’d say.
Here’s the summary of the staps at one glance
Want to optimize a page with a lead magnet for conversions and get more subscribers? Follow these 5 steps to get lots of traffic and new subscribers from StumbleUpon:
- Make sure your page delivers exceptional value and is optimized for StumbleUpon users.
- Create a StumbleUpon account
- Install a heat map software on your website and get everything in place to get the heat maps and the session recordings for your page.
- Submit the page to StumbleUpon. If it was already submitted once, do that trick with a duplicated page under a different URL marking it no-index no-follow.
- Watch your stats and the session recordings closely. Notice how far the users scroll and where they click. Make sure everything is working as intended. If not, update the page and recreate the heat maps.